← Projects · RF & antennas · X-band

8.5 GHz Microstrip Phased Array with Wilkinson Feed

A 3-element beam-steering patch array built up from its parts: a 1-to-3 Wilkinson power divider, an aperture-coupled patch, a delay-line feed network, the integrated array and a side-lobe taper. Designed in Keysight ADS and verified full-wave in Ansys HFSS.

Authors: Sajad Ghafouri, Mohammad Amin Khoshkam Substrate: Rogers RT/duroid 5880, 15 mil Type: design and simulation
array-factor model · 3 elements · d = λ₀/2 · steering to the design angle
8.5GHzcentre frequency, X-band
3× patchelements at d = λ₀/2 = 17.6 mm
−155.9°progressive phase per element
8.31dBipeak realized gain, integrated array
−20.7dBS11 of the feed network at 8.5 GHz
6.63dBirealized gain of one patch

A single patch has a fixed, broad beam. Feeding several patches with equal amplitude and a constant phase step between neighbours tilts the beam without moving anything: this project designs that feed for three elements at 8.5 GHz and checks every block on its own before the whole structure is simulated as one piece.

The work goes from component to system. The divider is designed and laid out in ADS, verified with Momentum and re-tuned in HFSS. The patch is sized from Balanis’ formulas and tuned by parametric sweeps. Delay lines add the phase step. The array is first simulated with ideal port excitations to get a reference, then with the real feed network connected. A final stage tapers the amplitudes to lower the side lobes.

HFSS model of the integrated array with its feed network
The complete structure in HFSS: feed network on the lower layer, three patches above the slotted ground plane.

Design values

Centre frequency f₀
8.5 GHz
Free-space wavelength λ₀
35.27 mm
Substrate
RT/duroid 5880, εr 2.2
Thickness, loss tangent
0.381 mm, 0.0009
Copper
18 µm
Reference impedance
50 Ω
Element spacing d
λ₀/2 = 17.63 mm
Steering angle θ₀
30° from the array axis
Phase step α
−155.9°
Guided wavelength λg
24.22 mm
Delay-line step ΔL
0.433 λg ≈ 10.5 mm
TRYθ₀
Beam-steering lab

How the phase step moves the beam

For a uniform linear array along the x-axis the array factor is largest where the phase added by the feed cancels the path difference between neighbours:

AF(θ) = Σ aₙ · exp[ j·n·(k·d·cos θ + α) ] → α = −k·d·cos θ₀ = −π·cos 30° = −155.9° → ΔL = (|α| / 360°)·λg = 0.433 λg

θ is measured from the array axis, as in Balanis. A beam 30° from the axis is 60° away from broadside, which is a large scan for a three-element array: the grating lobe then sits just outside the visible range and its shoulder shows up as a strong lobe on the opposite side. Move the slider to see it grow, then switch the taper: the taper removes the small lobe in the middle, not that shoulder.

Angle from array axis30°
Phase step α−155.9°
Delay-line step ΔL10.49 mm
Main beam found at—
Highest side lobe—
Half-power width—
Peak vs uniform0.00 dB

This is the textbook array factor of three isotropic or cos ψ elements with equal total input power, drawn on a 30 dB scale. It ignores mutual coupling, the real element pattern, the ground plane size and feed radiation, so it explains the HFSS patterns below but does not replace them. Dashed white: the uniform taper for comparison.

PHASEI
Keysight ADS · Momentum · Ansys HFSS

1-to-3 Wilkinson power divider

Three equal outputs are obtained by cascading two two-way dividers instead of building a three-way junction: an unequal Wilkinson (1 : 2) sends one third of the power to the first output and two thirds onward, and an equal Wilkinson (1 : 1) splits that remainder in two. Each output then carries one third, ideally −10·log₁₀3 = −4.77 dB.

The unequal stage uses curved quarter-wave arms to stay compact, and short matching sections at its outputs keep the interface to the second stage at 50 Ω. The connecting lines are meandered so that the three outputs end on one straight line, at least λ₀/2 apart, as the array needs. The layout was simulated in Momentum and placed back in the schematic as an EM block with the lumped isolation resistors.

In HFSS the same layout came out slightly off frequency and unbalanced, as expected when coupling and bend parasitics are solved in full. One parameter, the length of the curved section L_curve2, was swept and set to 2.075 mm, which centres the match at 8.5 GHz and gives the best power balance.

At 8.5 GHz

Ideal split per output
−4.77 dB
Momentum: S21 / S31 / S41
−5.10 / −4.96 / −5.05 dB
Momentum: S11
−16.5 dB
Momentum: isolation S32, S43
−29.1, −17.6 dB
HFSS: S11
−37.0 dB
HFSS: S22 / S33 / S44
−17.2 / −16.1 / −16.1 dB
HFSS: output isolation
≈ −25 dB
Tuned parameter
L_curve2 = 2.075 mm
ADS layout of the divider
ADS layout with the curved unequal stage and meandered lines.
Momentum S-parameters
Momentum co-simulation: split, input match and port impedances.
HFSS model of the divider
HFSS model of the same layout.
HFSS transmission to the three outputs
HFSS: the three transmissions meet near 8.5 GHz.
HFSS return loss of all ports
HFSS: return loss of all four ports.
Electric field on the divider
E-field: power flowing from the input into three branches.
PHASEII
Ansys HFSS

Aperture-coupled patch antenna

The radiator is a rectangular patch fed through a slot. The microstrip feed line is on one substrate, the patch on a second one, and the ground plane between them carries a rectangular aperture that couples the two. This keeps the feed network behind the ground plane, away from the radiating side, and gives three tuning handles: the slot, the stub that extends the feed line past the slot, and the patch itself.

Balanis’ equations for a directly fed patch give the starting size. With those values the first simulation resonated far from 8.5 GHz and did not reach −10 dB, because the slot and the second layer load the patch. Parametric sweeps then showed what each dimension does:

  • Patch length Lp sets the resonance: longer means lower frequency.
  • Slot length and width set the coupling, and with it the depth of the match and the bandwidth.
  • Stub length Lstub cancels the remaining reactance and deepens the S11 minimum.
  • Patch width Wp has only a small effect on the resonance.

The requirement was |S11| < −10 dB over a 2 % band around 8.5 GHz. The final design reaches −31.4 dB at 8.502 GHz; the markers on the final plot put the −10 dB band at 8.427–8.574 GHz, i.e. 147 MHz or 1.7 %. The pattern is broadside with 6.63 dBi peak realized gain.

Final dimensions (HFSS project)

Patch Wp × Lp
13.95 × 11.05 mm
Slot (Ws, Ls)
5 mm, 2 mm
Feed stub Lstub
5 mm
Feed line width
1.18 mm
Balanis start: Lp
11.4 mm

Result

S11 minimum
−31.4 dB at 8.502 GHz
−10 dB band
8.427–8.574 GHz
Bandwidth
147 MHz (1.7 %)
Peak realized gain
6.63 dBi, broadside
Top view of the patch
Top view of the patch on its substrate.
Initial S11
Before tuning: S11 with the textbook dimensions.
Final S11
After tuning: −31.4 dB at 8.502 GHz.
Pattern cuts of the patch
Realized gain in the φ = 0° and 90° planes.
3D pattern of the patch
3D pattern: broadside, 6.63 dBi.
Field on the patch
Field at 8.5 GHz: the slot under the patch couples the feed to the two radiating edges.
PHASEIII
Ansys HFSS

Feed network: divider plus delay lines

The divider already provides equal amplitudes. The phase step comes from extra line length: each output is one ΔL longer than the previous one, so the three paths are L₀, L₀ + ΔL and L₀ + 2ΔL with ΔL = 0.433 λg ≈ 10.5 mm. The extra length is folded into meanders, so the three ports still end λ₀/2 apart.

The line width is kept constant through the meanders, long closely spaced parallel runs are avoided to limit coupling, and all bends use the same corner style.

At 8.5 GHz the three outputs carry −5.12 to −5.20 dB, about 0.4 dB below the ideal −4.77 dB because of conductor and dielectric loss in the longer lines. Their phases are −155.5°, +48.6° and −108.9°: taken in array order, the steps are −155.9° and −157.5° against the −155.9° that was asked for.

At 8.5 GHz (HFSS)

Input match S11
−20.7 dB
Output magnitudes
−5.18 / −5.20 / −5.12 dB
Output phases
+48.6° / −108.9° / −155.5°
Phase steps in array order
−155.9°, −157.5°
Target step
−155.9°
Largest phase error
1.6°
HFSS model of the feed network
Feed network: divider and three meandered delay lines.
S11 of the feed network
Input match: −20.7 dB at 8.5 GHz.
Transmission magnitudes
Magnitudes of the three outputs.
Transmission phases
Phases of the three outputs, with markers at 8.5 GHz.
PHASEIV-A
Ansys HFSS

Ideal array: the reference

Before the feed network is attached, three copies of the patch are placed λ₀/2 apart and their ports are excited directly with equal amplitudes and the phases 0°, −155.9° and −311.8°. This shows what the array can do without feed losses and gives the pattern that the complete system should reproduce.

Mutual coupling between the neighbouring patches does not detune them: the active ports stay matched, with a −25.6 dB minimum at 8.513 GHz. The beam tilts to the design direction with 8.11 dBi peak realized gain. With the display limited to −10…+10 dB a second lobe on the other side is clearly visible, as the array factor predicts for a uniform taper at this scan angle.

Ideal excitation (HFSS)

Port phases
0° / −155.9° / −311.8°
S11 minimum
−25.6 dB at 8.513 GHz
−10 dB band
8.437–8.585 GHz
Peak realized gain
8.11 dBi
Gain over one patch
+1.5 dB
Three-element array model
Three patches with their own ports.
S11 of the array ports
Match under coupling: −25.6 dB at 8.513 GHz.
3D realized gain of the ideal array
Steered beam, 8.11 dBi, shown on a −10…+10 dB scale.
PHASEIV-B
Ansys HFSS

Integrated array with the real feed

The first attempt simply joined the three feed outputs to the three patch feeds. It did not work: the input match was poor, the gain dropped and the field plot showed the wave being reflected where the feed region met the antenna region.

CauseThe ground plane and the substrate of the feed network and of the antennas were separate pieces. A microstrip line needs its return current directly underneath; a gap in the ground is a hard discontinuity, even if the trace on top is continuous.

Two changes fixed it. The antenna substrate and ground plane were extended under the whole feed network so that both are continuous, and the radiation box was rebuilt with at least λ/4 of clearance on every side, after it turned out that its distance changed the computed realized gain.

The corrected structure steers the beam to the same direction as the ideal case, with 8.31 dBi peak realized gain. The input match at 8.5 GHz is about −11.5 dB, good enough but narrower than that of the feed network or the patches alone. A little radiation from the feed lines shows up in the pattern.

Complete system (HFSS)

Peak realized gain
8.31 dBi
Ideal reference
8.11 dBi
S11 at 8.5 GHz
≈ −11.5 dB
Ground and substrate
continuous
Radiation box clearance
≥ λ/4
First integration attempt
First attempt: feed and antennas on separate ground pieces.
Corrected model
Corrected: one substrate and one ground plane under everything.
S11 of the integrated system
Input match of the complete system.
3D realized gain of the integrated array
Realized gain, 8.31 dBi peak.
3D realized gain on a limited scale
Same pattern on a −10…+10 dB scale: main beam, second lobe and a small feed-line lobe.
BONUSV
Ansys HFSS

Side-lobe reduction with a Chebyshev taper

Equal amplitudes give the narrowest beam but the highest side lobes. A Dolph–Chebyshev taper puts more power into the centre element: the normalised power weights for this array are 0.5310 for the centre and 0.2345 for each side element, i.e. −2.75 dB and −6.30 dB.

With ideal port excitations the weights cost 0.3 dB of peak realized gain: 8.11 becomes 7.79 dBi.

To build it, the equal divider was turned into an asymmetric one by changing branch impedances and lengths, while keeping 50 Ω ports and the delay lines. The result is an approximation: the centre branch reaches −3.94 dB instead of −2.75 dB, the side branches −6.30 and −6.32 dB, and the input match is −14.3 dB at 8.5 GHz.

Trade-offIn the complete structure the narrow lobe between the two large lobes disappears and the pattern is cleaner, but the peak realized gain falls from 8.31 to 4.97 dBi. The large lobe on the opposite side stays, as in the array-factor model above: it comes from the wide scan angle, not from the amplitude distribution. The built taper also costs more gain than the ideal one, so this stage shows the mechanism rather than a finished design.

Power split at 8.5 GHz

Target, centre / side
−2.75 / −6.30 dB
Built, centre
−3.94 dB
Built, sides
−6.30 / −6.32 dB
Input match S11
−14.3 dB

Peak realized gain

Ideal ports, uniform → taper
8.11 → 7.79 dBi
Built, uniform → taper
8.31 → 4.97 dBi
Ideal uniform pattern
Ideal ports, uniform: 8.11 dBi, strong second lobe.
Ideal Chebyshev pattern
Ideal ports, Chebyshev weights: 7.79 dBi.
Built structure, uniform divider
Built, equal divider: 8.31 dBi.
Built structure, tapered divider
Built, asymmetric divider: 4.97 dBi, the narrow middle lobe is gone.
Output magnitudes of the asymmetric divider
Asymmetric divider: centre branch above the two side branches.
S11 of the asymmetric divider
Input match after the change: −14.3 dB at 8.5 GHz.
ALLΣ
Summary

Results at 8.5 GHz

BlockQuantityTargetSimulatedSolver
Power dividerSplit to each output−4.77 dB−4.96 … −5.10 dBADS Momentum
Input match S11< −15 dB−16.5 dB · −37.0 dBMomentum · HFSS
Output port matchlow−16.1 … −17.2 dBHFSS
Patch antennaS11 minimum< −10 dB−31.4 dB at 8.502 GHzHFSS
−10 dB bandwidth2 %147 MHz (1.7 %)HFSS
Peak realized gain—6.63 dBiHFSS
Feed networkInput match S11< −15 dB−20.7 dBHFSS
Output magnitudes−4.77 dB−5.12 … −5.20 dBHFSS
Phase steps−155.9°−155.9°, −157.5°HFSS
Ideal arrayS11 minimum< −10 dB−25.6 dB at 8.513 GHzHFSS
Peak realized gain—8.11 dBiHFSS
Integrated arrayS11 at 8.5 GHz< −10 dB≈ −11.5 dBHFSS
Peak realized gain≈ ideal8.31 dBiHFSS
Tapered arrayCentre / side power−2.75 / −6.30 dB−3.94 / −6.30, −6.32 dBHFSS
Peak realized gain—4.97 dBi (8.31 dBi before)HFSS

Values are read from the markers and scales of the simulation plots in the repository; values marked ≈ are read from an unmarked curve. All results are simulations; the array was not fabricated.

What the project showed

  • Circuit models are a starting point. The divider that was correct in the ADS schematic had to be re-centred in HFSS with one length; the patch sized from closed-form equations missed the band completely until the slot and stub were tuned.
  • The ground plane is part of every microstrip line. The integrated structure failed until the ground and substrate were continuous under the feed and the antennas.
  • Simulation settings change the answer. The radiation-box distance altered the realized gain until it was set to at least λ/4.
  • A taper is a trade. It removed the inner side lobe but cost gain, more so when built from real line widths than with ideal weights, and it cannot remove the lobe caused by the wide scan angle.